Tag: minors

The Brasov-based Tribunal for Minors and Family was
established in 2004. It was Romania’s s first such judicial establishment. It
was aimed as a pilot-project and was meant to stand as a model for identical
projects that were supposed to be carried all over the country until 2007, at
least in Romania’s major cities. It is just that, in 2022, the Tribunal for
Minors and family in Brasov is still a singular court, specializing in dealing
with civil and criminal cases where minors are involved.

All along, there have been voices pleading for the
dismantling of the Brasov-based court, on the grounds that its activity is
untenable. Financial reasons for its dismantling have been mentioned, among
other things, whereby the scope of the court was way too narrow as compared to
the human and material resources required for its functioning. In a recent
public discussion, hosted by PressHub.ro, the current president of the Tribunal,
judge Gabriela Chihaia, brought up her own reasons against the dismantling of
the aforementioned tribunal.

First off, on the premises at the Brasov-based Tribunal
for Minors and Family a special room was set up for the hearing of children. Through
the care of an association titled Women Get Involved, through sponsorship and
donations, the hearing of minors was made possible, for various cases they are
involved in, in a much friendlier environment, with relaxing, lively-colored
interior design and furniture. Children can experience traumas whose aftermath
can be long-lasting in their lives, so an environment where they can feel
relaxed is of utmost importance, when the hearing procedure is ongoing in
court.

Judge Gabriela Chihaia:

ʺIn an environment that is different from the court
room, which is austere, arid and where a certain set of procedures needs to be
followed, with people having to stand up the moment the court enters the hall
or when the petitioner and the respondent are appealed, with the culprit who
can be deprived of freedom and kept in custody or can be be subject to house
arrest or placed under judicial control or can be even free, being present in
the court room, with the culprit’s family or friends who, in certain cases, can
even be in the court room, or if the session we have is public or when, more
often than not, we have a minor individual as an injured party and then the
court session is closed to the public, being held outside the court room, in
the halls of the tribunal or in the courtyard, it goes without saying that the
minor individual having to face those people even at a mere visual level has
but one more trauma to experience, in addition to the trauma which exists by default,
once they are involved in a court case. So those special rooms enabled them to find
it a great deal easier to speak before the court. We had minors who first
played and who, even though they were more stressed out and more tense in the
beginning, they relaxed afterwards and said their statement much easier than
they would done that in a proper court room, that’s for sure.

There is a second reason why, in Romania, more
tribunals for minors and family should be set up: the number of cases involving
minors is growing. In the specialized court in Brasov, they are being dealt
with and ruled upon fairly rapidly, as compared to the general tribunal.

The President of the Brasov-based Tribunal, judge Gabriela Chihaia once again.

I think the number of such cases has
been growing, at once being slightly on the wane, as compared, at least, to the
Tribunal for Minors and Family. I began by job with
this court beginning January 1st, 2019, and I can say that I noticed
that the number of files where minor injured parties are involved, victims of
sexual crimes, most often, has been growing. We’re not speaking about an
exponential increase, though, yet we have such files all the time. With such a
specialization, we can better get ourselves organized on such files. For example,
for minor trafficking, a file dispatched to us as a first instance court or the
file of a murder perpetrated by a minor or attempted murder, perpetrated by a
minor or targeting a minor, we are very quick to deal with them, but our
readiness in solving them has to do with the criminal procedure standards and
practices because, concurrently, we need to comply with the deadlines
stipulated by the legislation, we need to abide by the parties’ right to defend
themselves, we need to enable all parties involved to make use of such rights in
a proper manner. And yet, apart from deadlines, we fare very well as regards
the deadline for solving the files proper.

At long last, given the specificity of
the Tribunal for Minors and Family, its employees have become specialists in
the matter of minors, in civil, but also in criminal cases.

Gabriela Chihaia:

ʺA regular tribunal solves
minors and family files together with the other files pertaining to a civil or
a criminal matter. And yet, ruling in several matters, it is obvious the judges
cannot specialize themselves in each of the aforementioned matters, given that each
and every one of them claims a specificity of its own. That is why, taking into
account that, throughout the years, emphasis has been laid on judges’ specialization,
such a specialized court can only be a good point for the organizing abilities
of the courts in our country, and implicitly, for the society we work for.

The project of establishing, in Romania, of tribunals specializing
in children and family-related issues has been nipped in the bud. However, such
a project has never been abandoned altogether, because of the need for the minors’
rights to be observed, also according to the international legislation and
recommendations. For many people, the existence of one such single court is
an error. (EN)